Blog 2: Automation Ethics

Blog 2: Automation Ethics

Prompt 1. Are there particular jobs or tasks that you think it’d be unethical to require robots to do?

Personally, I disagree that there are fundamentally unethical jobs for robots to do, as long as they are not sentient or sapient and as long as they are able to effectively and safely complete their tasks, because they cannot be morally harmed as non-living beings. However, in the discussion of what jobs robots should do, I do agree that there are many ways in which automation of tasks becomes unethical because of how it affects human beings, especially when it comes to questions of unemployment, risks associated with overeagerness to incorporate robots before they have reached full ability to complete their assigned tasks, and the costs of robot manufacturing and programming. Ultimately, I believe that robots should be incorporated into the industries only in order to benefit the general human population, and given the current economic climate of the United States and nature of existing artificial intelligence technology, the mass incorporation of artificial intelligence would be unethical at this time.

To address my first point, automation of manufacturing has led to increased unemployment, and therefore poverty and suffering, for newly-deemed “unskilled” workers throughout the entire history of industrialism. For example, when machines in factories replaced textile workers in the 19th century, the Luddite movement protested the overuse of machinery because of how it circumvented workers’ rights standards and put laborers out of work. Because of how machinery allows corporations to spend less on wages and puts blue-collar workers out of employment, the United States has experienced increasing socioeconomic inequality as wealth becomes more concentrated at the top of the social ladder. In an ideal world, we would use machines to benefit all of us; they would do much of our work for us, and most people would not have to work. Instead, the labor of the robots could effectively decrease the total human workload of the entire country, and the entire population would be wealthier and have more leisure time. However, we live in a capitalist society where corporations do not work for the common good, and the government does little to regulate inequality as a result of worker mistreatment. Thus, as long as our economic system continues to function in the way that it does, it will be unethical to replace human laborers with artificial intelligence due to the conditions of suffering that it would cause to the displaced workers.

The other reason why I believe companies and governments should not implement artificial intelligence at the current time is related to the current state of AI. Because AI is still a newly emerging form of technology, there is much left to do before AI can be used with complete safety and effectiveness. Firstly, AI still is not reliable enough to not make mistakes; after all, it is not capable of critical thinking that extrapolates beyond basic procedural knowledge to quickly make good decisions in times of emergent uncertainty. Thus, jobs that are high-risk and require wise snap decisions on the spur of the moment – such as surgeons or first responders – cannot be replaced with AI safely, at least not yet. Additionally, AI is not capable of wise or morally good decision making. We cannot trust that it has the ability to think of humanity’s good in its actions. Finally, generative AI is currently detrimental to the environment, as we have not yet figured out how to run data centers without negatively impacting the earth’s ecology. Not only will this cause problems in the long run, but the pollution of natural water systems as a result of AI’s overconsumption of freshwater has already begun to deprive certain populations of healthy food and water. Until we can figure out how to use AI without its negative effects on the environment, it is unethical to keep using it with the knowledge that it harms people and wildlife.

Beyond these points, the only jobs that I could see AI replacement being unethical fundamentally are related to emotional and social labor, such as caretakers of children, artists and other creatives, or mental health professionals. In this case, the social connections that we require from an early age cannot be replaced ethically by AI, as research suggests that simulated social relationships with AI agents do not confer the same psychological benefits of nor replace the psychological need for real human connection. However, I also believe that having fully capable AI agents complete these jobs – caring for children, writing books, and helping mental health patients – would not be unethical as long as they collaborate with rather than replace the current humans that do the emotional heavy lifting of the job. In these aspects, I think we can look at machines as a tool to take off the burden of menial tasks associated with any job, but the emotional labor required for these kinds of jobs cannot and should not be fulfilled completely by artificial intelligence.

In conclusion, the current system of the global economy and the current state of AI mean that the use of artificial intelligence in the current time would inevitably raise ethical problems. However, imagining an ideal world, I could see myself supporting the widespread use of artificial intelligence as long as we adjust our economic system so that AI can benefit everyone across socioeconomic strata, we develop the technology to use AI with complete assurance of safety and effectiveness, and we ensure that AIs do not completely replace jobs that require emotional labor and genuine interpersonal connection to keep society running well and our minds healthy.


Comments

Popular posts from this blog

Imagining District 10

Dating Aylmer